31 October 2012 Submitted by Ignacio Mas (not verified)

Peter, I don’t quite see why you are singling out safety as the key attribute of formal products. Sure I’d like them to be safer than informal options, but also more flexible, more convenient, cheaper, easier to build discipline, and with more choice. Bank offerings today are inferior to informal options on many of these dimensions. I don’t think safety would necessarily be the main attribute for poor people (a cow might die of disease, but it’s still a good investment), and even if it was I don’t think they would necessarily think formal options are safer than informal ones. I’m not saying that as a result people should be content with their informal options, what I am saying is that if banks don’t offer something that is clearly superior to what people already have and use, then don’t be surprised if bank accounts remain largely unused.

Kevin, more education is obviously better than less, but I think it’s too facile to blame the lack of take-up and usage of bank products on lack of financial education. If I invent a new widget and nobody buys it, would I be entitled to run to government or NGOs and plead with them to teach everyone to like my widget? It should be up to me to design my widget in a way that addresses a specific problem people have, to make it better than the alternatives out in the market already, to build it cheap enough and make it affordable, to invest enough in marketing so that customers become aware of its existence and its advantages, etc. Why should it be any different with banks’ widget-accounts? The problem is precisely that banks build products that demand too much change in how people think about and organize their finances.

It’s just like John says: it’s easier to fish with a worm that to get them to like chocolate – nice story, I hadn't heard that one before. And I agree with John’s point that if we have to rely on governments to innovate then we might as well pray.

John, the problem with entrenching innovation is that it demands that people do something different tomorrow to what they did today; that they trade a certain margin today for only the possibility of a bigger market tomorrow; that they focus on some hard-to-measure development activities rather than fixing some operational glitch that will hit revenue today; in short, that they accept the possibility that they might end up looking like fools if they are proven wrong. Thanks John for pushing us to take the harder path...

Ignacio

CAPTCHA